Archive for the 'ZERO PATENT' Category

ESOP Havoc In India Budget Proposal

Thursday, March 8th, 2007
The E`sob’story
March, 08th 2007
The incongruity of the tax basis arises largely from the fact that, unlike in any other country, India now seeks to tax the employer for a benefit/income which accrues to the employee, most of it without the employer having granted it or having any control over it.
      The recent proposal in the Budget for levying Fringe Benefit Tax (FBT) on employers Employees Stock Option Plans (ESOPs) is a complete reversal of the policy on the issue in place over the last 5-6 years. The current scheme exempts employees from taxation if they sell the scrips got in an ESOP plan within one year from exercise. The proposed amendment throws up issues of technical interpretations and the tax impact for the employer. Some of these may become clearer once the rules prescribing the Fair Market Value (FMV) for the purpose of valuing fringe benefits are notified. But till such time employers are saddled with a problem they never bargained for and will have to work out solutions to mitigate the unexpected problems. This article aims to briefly list out the harshness or multiple-wammy created by the introduction of this new provision. It also looks at the reasons which seem to be prompting the Finance Minister to introduce such changes and suggest some alternatives which may lead to a more rational way of taxation, should the Finance Minister wish to take away the concessional tax treatment granted to ESOPs. Key concerns   The key concerns from the employer’s perspective are: To start with, the employer suffers a hit to its Profit and Loss Account of the notional benefits to the employee at the time of the grant of the ESOP, equal to the discount in relation to the prevailing market value. While the P&L takes a hit, there is a question mark on the deductibility of such “expense” for the purposes of computing employer’s taxable income. On top of that, the employer is required to pay the FBT not only on the discount at the time of the grant but also in the appreciation of the value of shares in future (over which the employer has no control). To compound matters, such FBT paid by the employer is not tax-deductible and effectively equal to much higher post-tax expenditure. Further, as a lot of these employees who receive ESOPs may be mobile and render services in different tax jurisdictions between the grant and exercise of the stock option, they may end up having tax obligation abroad on some part of the benefits arising out of the ESOPs. While they may not themselves suffer double taxation, there would be an economic double taxation on account of the FBT paid by the employer not being creditable against the tax paid by the employee abroad. Lastly, foreign companies having presence in India by way of a branch/Permanent Establishment/ presence of employees may also end up having additional burden of tax by way of FBT on ESOPs, thereby substantially raising their effective tax in India. Interpretational issues   Apart from the above, quite a few interpretational issues are being debated in industrial/professi onal circles, andinclude: Will the FBT for employer be 33.99 per cent or a lower rate, based on valuation rules to be prescribed? What is the cost basis for employee for the purposes of determining capital gains when the options are sold at a later date? In fact, some quarters are also debating whether the proposed amendments will take away the obligation of the employees for payment of taxes on the stock option. Can the employer contractually/ tax-efficiently recover the FBT from the employee? Leaving aside the interpretation issues for the moment, it is suggested that, at a conceptual level, if the benefits of stock options are to be taxable, the levy must fall on the person deriving the benefit. Even where the benefit is sought to be taxed in the hands of the giver, it should be limited to the extent of the benefit granted and not beyond that. Such a scheme of taxation should also provide for matching deduction and credits so that economic double/multiple taxation is avoided. Unless such equity is bought about in the taxation, the concept of stock option may have a premature demise.               Suggested changes   In the light of the above, conceptually, the following changes should be considered by the Government in the scheme of stock option taxation: The FBT on the employer, if at all, should be limited to the discount to the market value on the date of the grant, as is required to be debited in the books of accounts under the accounting standards/guideline s applicable. Correspondingly, such expenditure should be clearly allowable as a deduction against the taxable income of the employer. Any forfeiture of such options resulting in disentitlement for the employee and reversal of such benefits should culminate in a corresponding deduction in the FBT obligations in future. The benefit to the employee in the appreciation of the share price over the exercise price may, if at all, be taxed in the hands of the employee at the time of the exercise. However, ideally, as the employee does not realise any gain at that stage, there should be no taxation then, but only post ultimate sale of shares. When such profit, which is in the nature of capital gains, accrues, it should be treated just like capital gains on shares, as applicable to any other investor. Given the importance of stock options to the growing economy of India, which is competing to reward its human resource, the industry should make a strong representation to the Finance Minister to withdraw the proposed amendments or to introduce a grand-father clause which seeks to apply the changes in law only prospectively. Nikhil Bhatia
(The author is Partner, BSR & Co, Mumbai.) Observations Nikhil Bhatia has rightly said Given the importance of stock options to the growing economy of India, which is competing to reward its human resource, the industry should make a strong representation to the Finance Minister to withdraw the proposed amendments or to introduce a grand-father clause which seeks to apply the changes in law only prospectively. Industry must protect the interests of the new generastion as the ESOPs are by and large given in the high tech areas of business . I f these are not protected there is a possibilty of more talent migrating from India to those countries where such taxes are not imposed . The August body of Parliament must DISAAPROVE this proposal of the Honourable FM to allow the wealth creation by those who help companies create intellectual and physical properties which are the present and future wealth of our nation . EVERYONE must read INDIA DEBATES-WHY SHOULD INDIA NOT GET THE PATENT OF “ARYABHATS” “ZERO   at http://blogs.mindbodynsoul.com/wp-admin/edit.php?paged=4 If you can’t support the R & D at least donot disturb whatever is going on . Be Blessed Her Holiness Maha Maya Ananta http://www.mindbodynsoul.com  
Tags:

Posted in CURRENT NEWS, FORTUNES, POWER POLITICS, INTERNET, MONEY, WEALTH, SUCCESS, WORLD AFFAIRS, INTERNATIONAL NEWS, INDIA, PATENT RIGHTS, ZERO PATENT, SCIENCE, PHILOSOPHY, EDUCATION, ZERO, BLOGS | 1 Comment »

MERRY CHRISTMAS - MONEY IS LOOKING FOR YOU

Saturday, December 9th, 2006
I recently joined AGLOCO because of a friend recommended it to me. I am now promoting it to you because I like the idea and I want you to share in what I think will be an exciting new Internet concept.
AGLOCO’s story is simple:
Do you realize how valuable you are? Advertisers, search providers and online retailers are paying billions to reach you while you surf.  How much of that money are you making? NONE!
AGLOCO thinks you deserve a piece of the action.
AGLOCO collects money from those companies on behalf of its members. (For example, Google currently pays AOL 10 cents for every Google search by an AOL user. And Google still has enough profit to pay $1.6 billion dollars for YouTube, an 18-month old site full of content that YouTube’s users did not get paid for!
AGLOCO will work to get its Members their share of this and more.
AGLOCO is building a new form of online community that they call an Economic Network. They are not only paying Members their fair share, but they’re building a community that will generate the kind of fortune that YouTube. But instead of that wealth making only a few people rich, the entire community will get its share.
What’s the catch? No catch - no spyware, no pop-ups and no spam - membership and software are free and AGLOCO is 100% member owned. Privacy is a core value and AGLOCO never sells or rents member information.
So do both both of us a favor: Sign up for AGLOCO right now! If you use this link to sign up, I automatically get credit for referring you and helping to build AGLOCO. http://www.agloco.com/r/BBBH2142
Tags:

Posted in CURRENT NEWS, FORTUNES, General, POWER POLITICS, INTERNET, ONLINE, HOME BUSINESS, MONEY, SUCCESS, WORLD AFFAIRS, INTERNATIONAL NEWS, US, INDIA, ZERO PATENT, MATHEMATICS, SCIENCE, SCIENTISTS, PHILOSOPHY, ASTRONOMY, EDUCATION, ZERO, COSMOS, PETROL, DIESEL, ELECTIONS, BLOGS, WEB | No Comments »

INDIA DEBATES-WHY SHOULD INDIA NOT GET THE PATENT OF “ARYABHATS” “ZERO”

Saturday, November 4th, 2006
Religion transcends science-Where science ends religion begins- ‘OSHO’ . This is a historical fact known and acknowledged by the world that India’s sage scientist ‘Aryabhat’ invented ‘ZERO’ ‘0’ .Zero is the most important part of the numerals without which the world cannot function. In the ancient times because of lesser population and pollution, the skies of the universe were free from the cluttering thoughts, images and sounds of the human minds. Indian sage scientists had direct communication with God the universal father and soul. During Narsimha Rao’s government  in India in the early nineties ,one small town lawyer raised  this issue when the government of  India signed the WTO and DUNCAN arrangements with world bodies .His  raising the issue of the patent of ‘0’  ‘ZERO’ of India stormed the country . The news was blasted all over in the print and electronic media. The issue created so much of heat that the parliament of India, the largest democracy in the world, was forced to take up this issue for discussion. People say this hot news reached the White House in America while Bill Clinton was the president. President Bill Clinton asked his secretary of commerce to urgently arrange a top cabinet meeting to discuss the issue. In the meeting the president asked the secretary of commerce to explain the situation .She said that the world acknowledges the historical fact that Aryabhat the great Hindu sage scientist of India had invented  the ‘0’ ‘zero’ on which today’s world economies and science functions. Infact nothing functions without ‘zero’. The noble president of the U.S.A asked the lady, the secretary of commerce to express the amount of damage it could cause to the U.S.A if the Indians are granted the rights to the patent of ‘zero’. She calculated and explained that Unites States of America would be sold to India within a week of granting them the patent of ‘zero’ due to the number of zero’s U.S.A punches every second. The entire U.S economy of trillions of dollars will be at the mercy of the Indians in South Asia. All the members of the cabinet including the mighty president were stunned and stone freed for a few moments. The president asked the lady in a low tone what can the Indians do if we do no grant them the patent of zero. She replied Mr. President we are the mightiest super power currently in this world on the planet earth. The Indians cannot do anything if we do not allow them the patent rights of zero. President grinned and announced the meeting is dismissed and we’re not gonna allow them the patent ‘0’ at the cost of America’s future .Let them do what they can, if they can. Indians could not help it and the matter subsided. The truth remains that Indian sage scientist not only invented ‘0’ but also invented decimal and calculated the distances from the sun and moon and other planets in our solar system without the scientific labs and the telescopes  ,but through there meditative minds. All true Indians worldwide are invited to rise and continue to participate in this greatest debate and give their comments on this blog, until it reaches its logical conclusion. This can change the cause of history of the future. Join into create a new history. Love God, Love Yourself, Be Blessed, Her Holiness Maha Maya http://blogs.mindbodynsoul.com Tags:

Posted in CURRENT NEWS, General, INTERNET, ONLINE, SUCCESS, WORLD AFFAIRS, INTERNATIONAL NEWS, US, INDIA, PATENT RIGHTS, ZERO PATENT, MATHEMATICS, SCIENCE, SCIENTISTS, PHILOSOPHY, ASTRONOMY, EDUCATION, ZERO, COSMOS | No Comments »